An ordinance set to be introduced at next Monday’s meeting of Ruston’s Board of Aldermen would increase the city’s residential electric rates significantly, if approved.
The amendment to ordinance 27-126 and 27-127 would hike the rate from $0.035/kilowatt-hour to $0.0485/kwh. Additionally, a provision that gives customers a lower rate from November through April will be eliminated.
Rates for customers other than residential will also be increased.
The Lincoln Parish Police Jury Ambulance Committee this morning voted 7 to 3 to recommend to the jury that the Ruston EMS be the ambulance and rescue provider for the part of Lincoln Parish outside Ruston city limits.
On a motion by Choudrant Mayor Bill Sanderson, and a second by Lincoln Parish Deputy Sheriff Mike Rainwater, the motion was stated thus: “We recommend to the Lincoln Parish Police Jury that we enter into a contract with the City of Ruston for rescue and EMS services,” Sanderson said.
He added, “according to their proposal.”
Voting yes were Sanderson, Dubach Mayor Mona Wilson, Dr. Jackie White, Downsville Mayor Reggie Skains, Rainwater, Police Juror Milton Melton, and Grambling Police Chief Tommy Clark.
The no votes were Committee Chair Charlie Edwards, Police Jury President Richard Durrett, and Simsboro’s Steven Yeich.
Lincoln Parish Fire Protection District No. 1 board chair Richard Aillet abstained.
Annette Straughter (LPPJ) and Walter Carpenter (Vienna Mayor) were absent.
The vote followed a failed motion by Melton, with a second by Yeich to send all the proposals to the jury without a recommendation.
“The three proposals be submitted to the Lincoln Parish Police Jury for review and take action – namely The City of Ruston, Pafford, and Lincoln Parish Fire Protection District No. 1,” he moved
That vote was the exact reverse of the winning motion. Voting yes were Edwards, Durrett and Yeich, with the rest voting no. Aillet abstained.
Several comments were made, including Lincoln Parish Sheriff Stephen Williams.
Said Williams, “What you’re asking (Fire District) Chief Reynolds to do, you’re setting him up for failure. I think you should take the five year contract with the city, and in the meantime figure out how you can get some more money funneled to your fire department and rescue and build them up. You’re putting our citizens at risk, and I just can’t sit back and be quiet about that anymore.
Reynolds had earlier in the meeting presented the committee with a proposal for outfitting the parish department with the personnel and equipment to do rescue operations.
He proposed adding 6 men full time and trucks and equipment. Operating costs were listed at about $475 to $500 thousand/year over five years, with equipment costs of $800 thousand spread out over four years.
At last week’s meeting of the Lincoln Parish Police Jury, Ambulance Committee Chairman Charlie Edwards noted, “I have not found an ordinance, a law, a federal mandate, or anything that says the police jury will concern themselves or be in the ambulance business. There are some juries that don’t. They say they’re not touching this.”
We looked at neighboring parishes to see what they do.
Jackson Parish – Has an ambulance service district created in 1998, and is funded by a 5.49 mil property tax and billings from insurance providers. Here is their website. Here is their 2021 audit.
Union Parish – In May, 2022, the Union Parish Police Jury selected Pafford Ambulance Service to be their provider. Here’s the minutes from that meeting. They show to have units stationed in Farmerville and Bernice.
Bienville Parish – A combination of Pafford and rural fire districts. Ringgold and Arcadia have Pafford ambulances stationed there, while Castor is served by Fire Protection District No. 6.
Claiborne Parish – Pafford, with units in Homer and Haynesville.
Police juries are governed by LA RS 33:1236, a very extensive statute.
According to the Police Jury Association of Louisiana manual:
A police jury/parish governing authority may operate an ambulance service or contract for the operation by others and may regulate and subsidize such services or operate the service in cooperation with other agencies or municipalities. Certain parishes are excluded while other parishes are granted additional authority.
Ruston Fire Chief Chris Womack reviewed the document and fielded questions from the committee members.
“The meat of this agreement is a five year agreement for the amount we discussed earlier in the year – $645,604,” he said. “The cost would increase – on the top of page three- by the consumer price index, Southwest Region,” he added.
Asked what that number was over the past several years, he said it had been in the 1 to 2 percent range until the last year, when it was in the 8% range.
“Parish residents will be only be liable for the amounts paid by government or commercial insurers, including Medicare or Medicaid,” Womack said. He added that no bills would be sent to uninsured patients.
Womack added that should the Lincoln Parish Fire District No. 1 ever took over the rescue duties currently provided by Ruston, the amount of the contract would be reduced by $100 thousand/year.
Several new employees would be added, Womack said, as call volume had increased significantly.
“We’re looking at starting right off the bat adding two per shift, and I see that growing,” he said.
Dubach Mayor Mona Wilson asked, “When is too much too much? This past week there was a 2 car vehicle accident, and I passed two fire district trucks and a Ruston EMS truck. Why did they need three?”
Womack said they always send fire trucks to vehicle accidents, as there is always a chance of fire or a fuel spill.
Pafford’s Shane Davis reviewed his company’s proposals and also took questions.
He said the proposal was for one year, with the option to renew annually every year for five years, at a cost of $360 thousand/year. There is no escalation clause, Davis added.
Pafford’s proposal is for ambulance emergency medical service only, with no rescue service provided. Ruston’s proposal is for both ems and rescue.
But Pafford provides transport service to all area and regional medical facilities, where Ruston carries patients to North Louisiana Medical Center only.
Said Davis, “The BLS (basic life support) is a actually a really good tool…you don’t want to tie up an ALS (advanced life support) truck on a BLS call. Taking someone to dialysis or from dialysis.”
There was a bit of discussion about how Lincoln’s 911 system would transfer calls to Pafford’s dispatch system. The plan calls for 911 to automatically switch parish calls to Pafford, with the 911 dispatcher relaying the pertinent info.
Ruston Fire/EMS has use of a system called ANI/ALI (automatic number identifications/automatic location information). That system provides detailed record of a 911 caller’s location and phone number. Presently, Pafford does not have that capability, but will in the future , Davis said.’
It was noted that about 60% of 911 calls are now via cell phone, which sometimes don’t provide as much information for ANI/ALI as does a landline.
The parish fire district did not provide a formal proposal for their rescue service, but will have one at the next committee meeting.
Here is their budget as presented at the August meeting.
The next meeting of the committee is next Thursday, September 22, 9 AM, Jack Beard Room, Lincoln Parish Library, 910 North Trenton.
It was perhaps the largest crowd at a Lincoln Parish Police Jury meeting since last year’s dogfight over funding for Four Paws Rescue – a hundred people or more – and they were there to vent about the Postel and ambulance controversies recently in the news.
At the end of the jury meeting when public comment is heard, several had their say.
James Skinner: “If Mr. Postel has done something wrong, immoral, unethical that he needs to be fired, he needs to know. We must do better for this parish.”
Bill Smith: “Not long ago there was $3 million in the air. And somebody from the jury voted to give part of that to Louisiana Tech and another part to the City of Ruston. All I could hear then was ‘they didn’t bring it to us, we didn’t get a chance to vote on it’
Ex State Senator Bill Jones: “What happened to Mr. Postel did not conform to normal employment practices. This jury is obligated to act in an open manner in how it handles its business, including employment matters.”
Chris Garriga: “When the ambulance vote came up, some of you (jurors) voted no, and haven’t talked to either the fire chief, a member from Pafford, or the sheriff. Accountability for the twelve of you has got to start being held.”
Rick Godley: “$30 thousand went on for how many decades? 1991, I think, but I could be wrong. If I’m understanding this right, we blew a deal of $120 thousand, but I could be wrong.”
The business part of the meetings were about as routine as it gets, even when the jury convened as the property assessment board of review. That is when the jury hears from property owners who have challenged their property tax assessments.
Lincoln Parish Tax Assessor Billy McBride told the group there had been but one challenge, but it was withdrawn last week.
We cannot recall that happening in the thirteen years of LPPJ coverage.
The jury’s Finance Committee approved with little discussion this year’s agency requests for appropriations.
There was one action item that caused a bit of discussion and a surprising vote outcome.
A couple of jurors had requested the Tuesday, 10/11/22 regular meeting be rescheduled for the next Tuesday (10/18), as local schools would be on fall break during the week of 10/11 – 10/14, and they had family vacation planned.
Ruston Sports RV Park, LLC will develop the twelve acre tract to handle up to 90 hook-ups with water, sewer, and power. The tract is located on Ball Park Road, just east of the indoor sports complex.
City Attorney Bill Carter said the site will be of benefit to the complex and the city, and Mayor Ronny Walker added that the company would foot the bill for construction with no cost to the city.
Ward Three’s Melanie Lewis had a couple of questions.
“Do we know who long this lease will be?” She also asked what the estimated value of the lease was.
Walker said the terms are still being negotiated, but expected that the city could be paid up to 20% of the company’s revenues. He added that an appraisal was underway to determine the value of the property for lease purposes.
He added that Interstate 20 RV traffic would likely use the park, in addition to rentals in connection to sports activities.
Prior to adoption of the city’s budget, City Treasurer Julie Speir noted that several capital projects were underway to include a new fire station, the animal shelter, street overlays and construction, sewer lift station upgrades, and water line replacement.
The Lincoln Parish Police Jury’s Ambulance Committee this morning voted to reopen negotiations with the City of Ruston to continue the city’s role of providing emergency medical services to areas outside the city limits of Ruston.
The committee can only make recommendations to the jury who has the final decision making authority.
After years of paying the city $30 thousand per year for the service, late last year Ruston Mayor Ronny Walker first demanded the jury quadruple that amount to $120 thousand. He then withdrew that offer and demanded $645 thousand per year.
The jury balked at the demands.
The motion as stated by committee member Dr. Jackie White was, “I would like the invite the city back to the table to give us a proposal for ambulance and rescue service for Lincoln Parish. At the same time they give it to us, I would like to give it to the police jury as well.”
The vote, however, was not unanimous.
Voting for: Annette Straughter (LPPJ), Bill Sanderson (Choudrant Mayor), Mona Wilson (Dubach Mayor), Jackie White (Health Hut), Reggie Skains (Downsville Mayor), Mike Rainwater (LPSO), Anne Grambling (LPSO).
Voting no: Richard Durrett (LPPJ), Steven Yeich (Simsboro)
Abstaining: Richard Aillet (LP Fire District), Charlie Edwards (Committee Chair), Milton Melton (LPPJ)
The vote came after some discussion on how to state the motion, and an amendment to the original motion that added the jury to the notification process.
Ruston Fire Chief Chris Womack told the committee that the last proposal made for $645 thousand per year would be the offer.
Said Womack, “Our offer hasn’t changed. I’ll put it back on the table.”
Asked about terms, Womack said the contract would need to be for five years, with a yearly inflation increase tied to the prime interest rate.
The next meeting of the committee will be Thursday, September 15, 9:00 AM at the Lincoln Parish Library’s Jack Beard Room.
Lincoln Parish News Online 